
I was sitting around with a few friends of mine, laughing and sharing horror stories from past relationships. One of them recently met a very nice girl on one of these internet dating sites, and the relationship has been going strong for a little over a year now. Frankly I think he wouldn’t mind being in one of those cheesy, success story commercials, with all the hugging and sweet talk. Soon the conversation shifted towards selling me on this whole internet dating craze, something I am not particularly a huge fan of.
I have always considered online dating as a sort of a last stand for my love life. I think people (including myself) see online dating as this bastion of loneliness and desperation. Where people, at their wits end with “the real world” go and try their luck to find love. They have their reasons for jumping in to the world of online dating. Some are terribly shy, and prefer the anonymity of it all, some don’t have the time to go out and meet people (which makes me wonder where they are going to find the time to date the people they meet online), and some do it to cheat on their spouses just do it for the sake of experiencing something new.
My main argument was that I do alright (understatement) with women and that I really don’t need to do the whole online dating thing. So he hands me a one month subscription card to a popular online dating service (I’d rather not say which one I used, but it’s a popular one). He goes on to tell me that he promises I will meet someone great and that I should totally check it out instead of “talking out my ass”. So I decided not only to take him up on it, partially out of surrender and mild curiosity, but also to detail my experience for you guys. So here goes…
The basic feel of these sites makes dating and that fun of “the chase” seem so mundane. I felt like a rich industrialist (or Eliot Spitzer), browsing a binder full of escorts. I am a guy who totally appreciates the personal, real life experience of meeting a girl and this totally removes that factor. It feels cold, and almost voyeuristic in a way. You sit a your computer, slowly scrolling through the pages, neatly sorted and organized, displaying results based on the criteria you specify. You read each profile, quickly glancing to the left, where a chart details your compatibility on 24 or so different categories…obviously a computerized process. Ultimately it’s just not fun. You are literally sitting there, forcing yourself to go through page after page, profile after profile, it can get monotonous.
The profiles posted read much like the next. A quick description of who they are, what they like to do, followed by a dissertation of what they want their “prince charming” to be like. Usually it’s some sort of existential reference about how they should love life, and be adventurous. On the flip side they want someone dependable, caring, “not afraid to share their feelings” and be a good listener. Littered throughout are small little references about how they are above “the games”, this usually hints at the rather turbulent love life that led them to this in the first place.
The women on these sites are surprisingly diverse, from different backgrounds and different circumstances. Some are obviously there for sex, and that’s apparent, usually the overly explicit “What I Do For Fun” section is a dead give away and some are there in search of a suitable father figure for their kid(s). However, I think most of the women on these types of sites tend to have their heart in the right place, and are driven to this because they are desperate (sorry I tried not to use this word), have been burned by a few bad relationships, or just want to give it a try so as to “experience something new”. Thats not to say that there aren’t a couple (yet another understatement) of crazies.
You can usually identify them by their eagerness to take your conversations to the next level in a short period of time. I definitely encountered one of those, who was eager to cut to the chase and get me on the phone. Not gonna happen. Fortunately my time spent in the trenches dating crazy girls in high school and college has given me a sixth sense and an amazing ability to see in to the future. I very much like my phone number and I don’t want to change it. It’s the level of anonymity that really defines the online dating world. Because ultimately you can test the waters a bit and see if this person has the potential to say…key the word “asshole” in to the hood of your car. These sites are usually good about having every type of communication self contained within the site, so as to let the user govern how much info they want to reveal. At the same time, that anonymity often leads to people adding a little fiction to their profiles, but frankly thats expected.
Unless you meet that special someone you are going to spend the foreseeable future rest of your life with, the value of these types of sites are minimal at best. Aside ridiculous fee structures (monthly payments billed all at once) and high costs, there are various a la carte options, obviously feeding to the obsessive. Mobile phone access for $4.99, Email Read Confirmation for $4.99 (Five bucks a month and you can keep clicking refresh until it’s read!), and some others that are equally as disturbing. Also the fact that a large portion of people on this site are inactive, as in they have created profiles but never checked them is a concern. This doesn’t help much considering that another large portion of people are active but are not paid subscribers. This does tend to limit the scope of these sites, and frankly the exorbitant cost is no doubt to blame.
Not too long ago, the debate was that the internet was slowly diminishing its users’ social skills and this was the focal point of the argument. The internet has successfully condensed the process of courtship, in to a mundane, effortless procedure made efficient for people to do on the fly, and to an extent that is true. However, finally experiencing this first hand, I can say that this in no way will replicate the fun of the real life experience. Call me a hopeless romantic, but I just love that feeling of being out somewhere and approaching a beautiful woman only to have a great conversation and a great time. It’s a rush…this however isn’t. This is impersonal, cold, computerized and can’t replicate the experience.
Would I recommend this to a friend? Probably not. My results were more or less exactly what I expected, however it really didn’t do anything for me. I know some people swear by this and that is cool, I am not saying it won’t work for anyone or that you are a fool for doing it. I am just saying that this isn’t the best way. What I have taken away from this experience is that this shouldn’t be your last resort. Don’t do this because you feel like you can’t get anyone without it. I am a firm believer that no one is out of anyones league and that love and relationships shouldn’t be left up to some computer matching system endorse by Dr. Phil (who is a jackass).
Sadly in the end, internet dating sites are just huge matchmaking machines that “match you on 70 levels of compatibility” or follow the “key values for success”. It’s these gimmicks that communicate the mantra of the average online dating site. “Don’t worry, we are going to use all this BS to find your soulmate guaranteed. You just sit back and relax and we’ll take care of all the romance for you!” Folks get out there. Go to fun places, do fun things, live life and the perfect match will find you. Peace Out!